It is literally a one stop shop for a whole body super food! Phytoplankton also packs in the benefits of trace minerals, carotenoids (antioxidant), chlorophyll, essential amino acids, protein and vitamins. As I understand it, what we want as pet parents is an oil that is higher in Omega-3 fatty acids and plant-based oils have Omega-3 in the form of ALA, which dogs can't efficiently convert to EPA and DHA (which is what they need). If anything changes, and I find a source, I will update immediately. As our society changes and scientific progress is being made, we now have an abundance of information available to us about ways to improve the lives of our pets. ( Log Out / In the past I’ve given my dogs Mercola Krill Oil and Dr. Dobias’ Feel Good Omega, but as of late have been giving them Adored Beast Phytosynergy. It is called an essential fatty acid for a reason! Omega 3’s (EPA and DHA) also improve brain function, prevent dementia, slow aging, promote skin, coat and hair growth, improve joint health and reproductive health. A couple of years ago, I wrote a blog post explaining why I don't give phytoplankton to my dogs. 2) Can Replace Toxic … I also have a relationship with Darwin’s Natural Pet Products as a customer; please note that Darwin’s Pet does not provide free food for my pets. This is because unlike people, dogs can’t convert plant based sources of omega 3 (such as flax) and therefore need the DHA and EPA in pure form. This basically means when the oil mixes with oxygen, the fat particles break down into smaller compounds such as MDA (malondialdehyde) and contain free-radicals. The most effective solution for the overabundance of these oils and the diseases they create, is introducing Omega 3. I'll use Rodrigo as an example to show the cost difference between fish oil and phytoplankton. “Omega-3 fatty acids make up half the body weight of phytoplankton called thraustochytrids. Farm raising keeps harvesting them from affecting our oceans. This was not an issue for the dog’s ancestors, because their diets were not nearly as laden with these oils as they are today. If it isn’t, it’s essential to ask for a Certificate of Analysis (COA) from the manufacturer before you know the analysis is legitimate. Most dogs are mineral deficient and it also contains extra added benefits including trace minerals, manganese, selenium, chlorophyll, magnesium, iodine, antioxidants (such as superoxide dismutase which removes toxins and heavy metals from the body), essential amino acids, protein, vitamins and carotenoids. I also already use spirulina. Because our oceans are so heavily contaminated we also have to be concerned about industrial chemicals such as PCB’s, dioxins and pesticides. This means when eating fish from the contaminated waters, the dog is eating the toxic selenium directly because it is stored in the bones. Plus, it’s packed with phospholipids, astaxanthin, and carotenoid, which are not found in traditional fish oil. Phytoplankton is a perfect source of Omega-3 and fatty acids DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) and EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid), nearly double as in fish oil. These fish carry with them the extra threat of being contaminated with radiation poisoning. However, it?s interesting to note that the benefits of fish oil extend beyond a dog?s physical attributes. Today our meats contain drastically higher amounts of omega 6 and 9 due to what these animals are fed. Sadly, no. You can use a text widget to display text, links, images, HTML, or a combination of these. Sometimes its hard to tell if an oil is rancid but it is CRUCIAL information because rancid oil will do a lot more harm than good! Dogs . This can be overwhelming, but one thing that has become abundantly apparent, is that dog’s need Omega 3’s in their diet. Safe Ways to Give Your Dog Omega 3, Titer Testing and the Dangers of Over-Vaccinating, 5 Easy Tips to Extend Your Dogs Life, That You Can Do TODAY! Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Fish oil is also popular for decreasing inflammation, increasing a dog?s stamina, and improving its immune system. When it comes to chewable supplements, their Omega Bites line of soft chews are our top choice. Fish oil is a dietary supplement high in omega-3 fatty acids. Despite what I share in this blog post, the benefits of phytoplankton haven't changed and I'll continue adding it to my smoothies now that I'm on an “I need to get healthy” kick and my dogs' meals. Linoleic acid (C18:2n-6) and arachidonic acid (C20:4n-6) are two of the major omega-6s.”. And, according to Dr. Karen Becker, dogs and cats can only absorb Omega-3s from … And yes, cod liver oil, salmon oil, and other fish oils for dogs are considered supplements. Omega 3 fatty acids (fish oil) and glucosamine are both commonly recommended for dogs with hip and elbow dysplasia, as well as those suffering from arthritis. Rancid fish oil is a huge problem in the industry and this can have life threatening effects on a dog. Bonnie & Clyde and Life Line offer smaller sizes. Not only that, but it may also benefit your dog’s skin health, immune system, osteoarthritis, and more.” bncpet. Rancid oils often have a smell to them. For more info on this, or a purchasing reference, this article is a good start. Salmon from the pacific northwest is not safe due to the presence of a particular parasite that can be deadly, its just not worth the risk. It's great, when fresh, for puppies due to the high levels of DHA & EPA for brain & eye development , but for older dog's done with growth, we can help them with pain and inflammation in a safer way that will be easier on their … I do my best to look at every angle. Many people choose Sardines and Hearing because they are both high, well-balanced sources of DHA and EPA and dogs seem to eat them more easily. They don’t have bones. They were kind enough to send me several packages recently because I'm such a fan. Nope. These charts are a great resource and quick reference guide for selecting raw fish! Thanks for the great article! Initially, I thought this was a steal as compared to similar products and because a bag will last a couple of months with all four of my dogs. I personally try to do a combination because it is what works for us. Also, the added antioxidant “benefits” have absolutely no proof of making any type of effective difference. Too much omega 6 and 9 can lead to inflammation, chronic disease, faster aging and slower healing. One thing that's clear from the Certificate of Analysis is that phytoplankton is rich in chlorophyll, which is fantastic. I am an avid dog lover an proponent of animal happiness, health and longevity. I am constantly doing research on helping my rescue dog achieve the BEST life possible. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Some fish oil supplements for dogs are 100% fish oil, while others include vitamin E or other helpful nutrients. The phytoplankton is obviously providing something she needs and wasn’t getting before. Source is extremely important when using fish oil. Her coat is like black glass, actually better than the other dogs. Is Phytoplankton a replacement for fish oil? Is it Better Than Fish Oil? Fish oil, in general, is a controversial topic because of the overfishing and the harm that the fishing industry does to the environment. Each one is different, but you can tailor it to be the exact amount that your dog needs. I’m just trying to present all the facts. Whats worse is that MOST sardines come from Japan (where the radiation levels are the highest) and even companies that have no indications on their label, may be sourcing their sardines from these contaminated waters. ( Log Out / Many forms of pollution have laid waste to the original home of marine phytoplankton. I had always supplemented with fish oil until then. Took possession of 2yr old amstaff, former owner neglected dog. Initially, my recommendation would have been phytoplankton, but now I'm not so sure. It contains the other benefits that phytoplankton has, and I have had time to source this correctly. I was wrong. I have not had enough time to properly source phytoplankton, so I will not purchase this supplement yet. * A good reference guide for sardines is Here I buy coles or crown prince now, *NOTE: When using fish oil it’s good to look for one with vitamin E in it. Edit them in the Widget section of the, Phytoplankton, Fish oil or Raw Fish? It’s bioavailable and easy to measure so I see no need to replace it. You can research the fish source, but it is not as easy to be confident it has been tested for purity (and you can’t do this at all with fresh fish), The safest source seems to be cephalopods such as octopus and squid. Fish bones can be a danger if swallowed whole instead of chewed (but processed fish is only considered safe for humans). Better is a relative term. But, you can get far more benefits when you use krill oil for dogs. Additionally, dog fish oils are not magic health supplements for dogs: they may take weeks to show visible effects, they aren’t the cheapest, but they are indeed wonderful in the long run. After an exhausting amount of research, I basically came to the conclusion that there is no easy answer to this. But does your dog need both, or is one better than the other? Zesty Paws is all about dog supplements and they’re one of the most trusted names in the space. Feel Good Omega which I also take myself, and for spirulina I use Green Min. Veterinarian's Assistant: I'll do all I can to help. There are approximately 51 teaspoons in an 8.5 fluid ounce bottle of Life Line Wild Alaskan Salmon Oil, equating to about $0.20 per teaspoon (based on a $10 bottle). Question concerning phytoplankton, is it better than dinovite omega fish oil for dogs health? There are many contributing reasons for this, but one simple reason is livestock feed. If you have a dog that is constantly dining on grass, it could be because your dog has a digestive issue OR it could be because your dog is supplementing his or her diet with the chlorophyll that is present in the grass. So now I have all three dogs on the phytoplankton. Some may recommend chia seeds, flaxseed, hemp, or pumpkin seed oil, and while there are quality oils out there, I don't think these are the best options for dogs. I know that plant based sources aren’t as easily absorbed by dogs, but does that include phytoplankton? Do Calming Dog Beds Work for Anxious Dogs? Freshwater phytoplankton does not produce EPA. Zesty Paws offers 3 different varieties of Zesty Bites currently – a Chicken flavor and a Bacon flavor that derive their Omega-3s from fish oil… Fish & Aquatic Pets Go Search EN Hello, Sign in Account & Lists Sign in Account & Lists Orders Try Prime Cart. Dog’s can’t produce Omega 3’s on their own and this is what makes it such an important supplement for them to get. Get phytoplankton grown in bioreactors. Phytoplankton is now on many lists of Super Foods because of the benefits (listed below) and it's said to be less toxic than fish oil and salmon oil while protecting our oceans from over-fishing. 1. When choosing a fish oil for dogs, read the label to ensure that the supplement you choose provides the amount of omega-3 fatty acids that your veterinarian recommends. Phytoplankton is micro-algae in the plankton family, while seaweed is a macro-algae. This is misleading though, because I listed the universal pros in the heading. However phytoplankton is comprised of tiny nano particles, so the body’s mucous membranes can absorb it. Both of these damage proteins, DNA, other cellular structures and can lead to disease. Each and every leading source available today has pros and cons. This deep dive now has me questioning what I believed about phytoplankton. ( Log Out / Too much of any of these may cause very adverse effects including difficulty clotting blood, slower would healing and proper immunity responses where inflammation is necessary to trigger the body’s appropriate response. Fish oil is also volatile-it can go rancid quickly if not stored properly and then do more harm than good. Why Krill vs Fish Oil For Dogs. Source is extremely important when using fish oil. It would be impractical to ingest enough phytoplankton to match a spoonful of pure fish oil’s quantity of EPA, so if you’re giving your dog fish oil for joint health or some other highly specific … I do like adored beast apothecary and I think there are other reasons to use it but considering the serving size, I have trouble believing I’d get enough omega 3 to make it useful in that way. I've been giving my dogs phytoplankton formulated for pets, which is available on Amazon.com. It already comes in an easily digestible source so these nutrients can be absorbed in to the system more easily than if they came from other plant based sources. Since the ETA found in the green lipped mussel is hundreds of times more potent than the EPA found in fish oil, you can give your dog a comparatively lower dosage. So, with this information, I can see that the phytoplankton I'm giving to my dogs is higher in Omega 3 fatty acids when compared to the amount of Omega 6 fatty acids (this is good). Flaxseed oil: This oil is high in alpha linolenic omega-3s, which puts it in the same ballpark as wild fish when it comes to boosting heart health. Farm raised fish often contain growth hormones and residue of drugs meant to prevent diseases. CopyrightÂ© 2011-2020 Kimberly Gauthier.Â Articles may not be reproduced in whole or in part without written consent of Kimberly Gauthier [that’s me!]. Despite my initial thoughts, I continued to do my homework and changed my mind when I did find an affordable source, however, today, I wonder if my first instincts were correct. The ocean is overwhelmed with pollutants. Neither is a sufficient source of Omega-3s.”, Did you catch that? Garbage, oil, chemicals, factory runoff, acid rain… the terrifying list of contaminants could fill a book. There are two major classes of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs), Omega 3 and Omega 6 fatty acids. Most Fatty fish contain approximately 1-2 grams of omega 3 per 3 oz serving, but this varies greatly between fish (this example was taken from salmon). My hope is more information will be available at some point but for now fish oil is my best bet. A whole food supplement, it offers a beneficial array of vitamins, minerals, amino acids and fatty acids, including EPA. Dark glass is always a safer option. Today, we're going to talk about a supplement that I've been giving my dogs and promoting as a superior alternative to fish oil. Sardines contain approximately 1.8 g of omega 3 per 4 oz serving. I haven’t had the experience of fish oil going rancid so I don’t know if it has something to do with the brand or the container. Oysters contain about 558 mg omega 3 per 3 oz serving and also have B12, iron, copper, calcium, phosphorus, selenium and zinc. Omega-3 for dogs, infused into many good quality dog food diets, is known to relieve inflammation, maintain eye, bone and brain health, and support the immune system. I suspect it’s more, but I don’t care. Omega 3 fatty acids and glucosamine supplements are different. I wasn't convinced that it was an affordable alternative and I questioned being able to find a quality source. The contents of marine phytoplankton is also worth investigating for its literal treasure trove of … Too much can be toxic and too little can cause damage as well. The purpose of this blog is to have a place to share what I find. Even wild and sustainably caught fish pose a risk. Krill Oil vs. (This also makes fish oil made from small fish more risky.). The ratios we see represent the carbon atoms and double bonds associated with each fatty acid. Similarly, EPA is known as C20:5n-3 and DHA as C22:6n-3. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Fish aren’t born with high levels of omega-3 fats. Many larger fish are simply too high in toxins to ever be safe including, tuna, mackerel, marlin, orange roughy, shark, swordfish, tilefish and grouper to name just a few. While phytoplankton is the richest plant source of Omega 3 oil, the comparisons to fish oil are not necessarily appropriate. The cons lists look much longer than the pros list on these. We often see “organic,” “natural,” and other marketing terms on the packaging and what the terms imply isn't always true. Phytoplankton food contains the Omega-3 essential fatty acids nearly double the amount of omega-3 fats by weight as fish oil. by Kimberly | Jun 14, 2019 | Dog Supplements | 3 comments. What's NOT so clear in the Certificate of Analysis is the Omega 3 fatty acid levels because I'm not used to reading these types of documents. Sep 5, 2019 - I've been adding phytoplankton to my dogs' raw food diet for a year because I thought it was a superior and affordable alternative to fish oil. I choose to supplement with a fish oil that I’ve had years to research and trust, add occasional green lipped mussel powder and feed a small amount of raw fish, also from a trusted source. The best sources of omega-3 for dogs are small fatty fish like anchovies or sardines, fish oils made from these small fish, krill oil or phytoplankton. So while I add many seeds to my dogs' raw diet, including chia seeds, I don't think that they are a substitute for a quality fish oil. It has a better variety of nutrients compared to fish oil. She just never had the shine my other dogs and any healthy Rottie has. Most fish oil has some of this before you even buy it. I will continue doing my homework and hope to return to this blog post to update it with an option. The popularity of krill oil is depleting food sources for the marine animals that feed on krill. This means phytoplankton provides energy straight to the body’s cells. This may not come as a big shock to you, but our oceans are filled with heavy metals, toxins, and undesirable pollutants. As our society changes and scientific progress is being made, we now have… I am not a veterinarian, canine/animal nutritionist, or dog trainer. The dosage information comes from DogAware.com. I am a blogger, and all information shared is based on my personal experience with my dogs and research about raw feeding, canine health, and nutrition that I do for my dogs.Â Please do not use content from this blog in place of veterinarian care.Â I do not offer coaching or consultations; the most I can do is share my personal experience. The body can only produce a small amount of DHA from other fatty acids, so it's essential that our dogs and we, their humans, get our DHA from food and supplementation. The product that I buy for my dogs has measurements in grams, so let's get on the same page: All that being said, I do believe that phytoplankton is an alternative to fish oil, I simply don't believe that it's a budget-conscious alternative to fish oil. What is the matter with the dog? This brings me to the main point of this article: trying to decide which source of marine omega 3 is best. All that being said, I do believe that phytoplankton is an alternative to fish oil, I simply don't believe that it's a budget-conscious … If your fish oil supplement is a pure fish oil it may be safe to also give to your dog but you should discuss it with your veterinarian first to be sure. Because every kibble I could find has at least one of her allergens, I finally switched her to raw. “It can help prevent the oxidative damage in omega-3 oil. It's easy to make the mistake and think phytoplankton is a type of seaweed, but this isn't correct. This can even extend to slowing down memory loss. The best sources of these for our dogs, come from the ocean. View all posts by The Healthy Dog Blog. Phytoplankton = $17/day; Life Line Wild Alaskan Salmon Oil = <$0.20/day; Alternatives to Phytoplankton. They also shared their Certificate of Analysis with me because I was curious about the nutrient makeup of phytoplankton, and this isn't the information that you can easily find online. Great question. (Amounts should be limited here and depend on what else the dog is eating because vitamin D is fat-soluble. Benefits of EPA over ALA (the flaxseed vs fish oil/marine phytoplankton debate) Of the three Omega 3 fatty acids, EPA, DHA and ALA, it is ALA most commonly found in the vegetable kingdom. Rancid fish oil is a huge problem in the industry and this can have life threatening effects on a dog. Just like your dog, they need to get omega-3 in their diet. Both fish oil and krill oil can offer you a healthy source of omega-3s. As our society changes and scientific progress is being made, we now have an abundance of information available to us about ways to improve the lives of our pets. “PUFAs are frequently designated by their number of carbon atoms and double bonds. Change ), This is a text widget. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. The dog ownesr that provides their dog with both glucosamine and fish oil supplements see much better results in not only their dog’s joint health, but their overall well-being and happiness as well. Keep the Tail WaggingÂ® is a personal blog and a minority/woman-owned business.Â I, Kimberly Gauthier (owner), am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Her skin problems (chronic hot spots) cleared, but her coat, which never looked good, didn’t improve. My dogs are getting fish in their diet regularly, so maybe that makes a difference, but the allergy girl was getting both fish and fish oil before the phytoplankton. Fish Oil for Dogs. The omega-3 fatty acids in fish oil are extremely vulnerable to oxidative damage. They lack bones that store radioactive substances and have very short life spans that keep their mercury and other heavy metal toxin levels at a minimum. … The phytoplankton that I order for my dogs is about $34 per bag. Fish from these waters are testing positive for radioactive particles such as cesium-37 and strontium-90 which can be deposited into bone marrow when ingested and cause innumerable problems including leukemia and cancer. Krill is a good source of omega 3 but it is being over-fished and is not stable for the environment. So buy your supplements from a reputable source that you trust. And you can get them boneless. On its own, EPA reduces cellular inflammation, but everything I've read tells me that our dogs need EPA and DHA together; more EPA, than DHA, but they work together. Phytoplankton food contains the Omega-3 essential fatty acids nearly double the amount of omega-3 fats by weight as fish oil. When produced properly and stored in dark glass ONLY, oxidation levels are usually much less. A lot of fish oil comes from salmon sources in the pacific. One of my Rottweilers has had skin problems all her life, which finally led to allergy testing. Some fish oil products have flavorings, sweeteners, or other added ingredients that may not be good for your dog. A proprietary combination of freshwater and marine phytoplankton does, but in only miniscule amounts. All my research has just caused more confusion lol! I use fish oil primarily to balance fats and it’s very easy to look at the label and figure out exactly how much omega 3 I’m getting. They really should have this in their diet. Omega-3s fatty acids (EPA and DHA) found in fish oil can improve many conditions in dogs. Sure, fish oil provides EPA and DHA too, but a primary benefit of krill oil for dogs is that it contains higher levels of EPA than fish oil. I confess to not having done your analysis of phytoplankton but to simply giving it a try. Rodrigo needs .37 grams of EPA and DHA daily, which would mean that he'd go through half a package of the marine phytoplankton I purchase DAILY to meet his daily needs. This translates to meaning marine animals and algae. NOTE: If you are using fish oil: Using just any fish oil truly is not safe. Fish oil for dogs and cats are toxic to pets because they oxidize when exposed to oxygen and this actually increases inflammation in pets. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. And they get it from phytoplankton. For source transparency the oil must be third party tested. Phytoplankton contains Omega-3 essential fatty acids DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) and EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid). Like many of the other healthy oils, flaxseed oil also helps with mobility for arthritic dogs, and can aid in blood pressure and kidney function. While those pollutants aren’t good for our dogs to ingest, Omega-3 fatty acids are.